Notorious Wills of the Rich and Famous

Why Do Celebrity Wills End Up in Court?

Celebrity estate disputes are not caused by a lack of resources or access to legal advice. They happen for the same reasons ordinary Wills are contested: ambiguous language, failure to update documents after life changes, dying without a Will at all, or leaving out family members who feel entitled to a share.

The difference is scale. When hundreds of millions of dollars are at stake, even distant relatives and strangers have a financial incentive to challenge the estate. These five cases illustrate the most common estate planning failures — and the lessons apply to everyone, regardless of net worth.

What Happened with Anna Nicole Smith’s Estate Battle?

Anna Nicole Smith’s estate saga involved not one but two separate disputes — one over her husband’s fortune, and another over her own estate after her death.

The Marriage and the Missing Will

Anna Nicole married J. Howard Marshall in 1994. He was 89; she was 26. Marshall had amassed a $1.6 billion fortune in the oil business. When he died just 14 months later, the bulk of his fortune went to his son E. Pierce Marshall. Anna Nicole was not mentioned in the Will at all.

She claimed her husband had promised her half of his fortune but had never updated his Will. This launched a legal battle that lasted 20 years.

A Legal Battle Across Two States

The case became extraordinarily complicated because it was filed in two jurisdictions:

• Texas probate court: Ruled in favor of Pierce Marshall
• California bankruptcy court: Awarded Anna Nicole $475 million after Pierce sued her for defamation in that jurisdiction, giving her the opportunity to counter-sue

The case reached the U.S. Supreme Court twice. Both times, the highest court ruled in favor of Pierce Marshall. By the time of the second ruling, both Anna Nicole and Pierce had died.

Anna Nicole’s Own Estate Planning Failure

Anna Nicole died of an accidental drug overdose in February 2007 at age 39. She had left her entire estate to her son — who had predeceased her in September 2006. Her five-month-old daughter Dannielynn was not mentioned in the Will. A custody battle followed, with four men claiming to be Dannielynn’s father. DNA testing confirmed Larry Birkhead as the father, and Dannielynn became the sole heir.

What Was the Dispute Over Robin Williams’ Will?

Robin Williams left his $100 million estate to his three adult children — Zachary, Zelda, and Cody. His Will included a provision allowing his wife, Susan Schneider Williams, to live in their shared home in Tiburon for her lifetime, with the property ultimately passing to his children.

What Caused the Dispute?

Williams had updated his Will shortly before taking his own life in August 2014. The major assets — the house and the money — were clearly assigned. The problem was personal property. His Will did not clearly specify who would keep items inside the home: clothing, fossil and graphic novel collections, and personal photographs.

How Was It Resolved?

His widow argued that by granting her the right to live in the house, Williams had implied the contents were hers. His children argued the Will clearly intended all personal possessions to go to them. The parties settled out of court in October 2015. Susan Schneider Williams retained the home, received some personal items including a watch and wedding gifts, and a trust was established for property maintenance expenses.

Lesson: Be specific about personal property in your Will. Items with sentimental value — photographs, collections, clothing — should be explicitly assigned to named beneficiaries to prevent disputes.

What Happened to Prince’s $500 Million Estate?

Prince died on April 21, 2016, without a Will. His estate was estimated at approximately $500 million and expected to grow substantially — similar to how Michael Jackson’s estate generated hundreds of millions after his death.

Who Claimed Prince’s Estate?

Because Prince died intestate, the court had to determine his legal heirs. Dozens of people came forward claiming to be blood relatives. DNA testing eliminated the false claims. A judge ruled that six people qualified as heirs: his full sister Tyka Nelson and five half-siblings.

Why Did the Case Drag On?

Beyond the six recognized heirs, two additional claimants emerged — the daughter and granddaughter of Duane J. Nelson, who they claimed was Prince’s “brother.” This raised a complex legal question: what is the legal definition of “father”? Duane was named on a birth certificate as the father but was not genetically related. The court had to determine whether legal or genetic parentage applied.

What About His Music and Legacy?

With no Will in place, there was no provision for who would control Prince’s music, brand, image, and legacy. For comparison, Jimi Hendrix also died without a Will. His estate passed to his father, and when his father died, control went to Hendrix’s adopted half-sister — someone Jimi had met only a couple of times.

How Did Howard Hughes’ Missing Will Create 20 Years of Chaos?

Howard Hughes died in 1976 as one of the richest people in the world. He had inherited $1 million at age 18 from his parents’ oil tool business and built an empire spanning oil, aviation, and film. No verified Will was ever found, and he had no living spouse or children.

Was a Will Ever Found?

A document surfaced at the headquarters of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Salt Lake City, purporting to be Hughes’ Will. It divided his estate into 16 equal shares, including one to the Church and one to a man named Melvin Dummar.

Dummar claimed he had picked up a disheveled man in the Nevada desert in December 1968 and driven him to Las Vegas. The man said he was Howard Hughes. Despite the compelling story, the court dismissed the document as a hoax.

How Was the Estate Distributed?

Hughes’ cousins were his closest known relatives and initially received shares. However, over 1,000 additional claims were eventually filed. The estate, calculated at more than $1.5 billion, took over 20 years to distribute as land and assets were slowly liquidated.

How Much Did Leona Helmsley Leave to Her Dog?

Leona Helmsley — nicknamed the “Queen of Mean” — left one of the most unusual Wills in American history. After serving 19 months in prison for tax evasion and inheriting an estimated $5 billion from her husband Harry (whose assets included the Helmsley hotels and the Empire State Building), she died in 2007 with an estate worth approximately $8 billion.

Who Got What?

Most of her estate went to the Leona M. and Harry B. Helmsley Charitable Trust. She left instructions that the trust benefit dogs, but because those instructions were separate from the trust documents, a court ruled the trust was not bound by her wishes.

Her treatment of family was characteristically harsh:

• Two grandchildren: Received $5 million each — on condition they visit their father’s grave once a year
• Two other grandchildren: Completely disinherited
• Her Maltese dog “Trouble”: Originally left $12 million

What Happened to Trouble?

The disinherited grandchildren challenged the Will. Trouble’s inheritance was reduced from $12 million to $2 million. The excess was split: $4 million to the charitable trust and $6 million to the previously disinherited grandchildren. Trouble died in 2010. The dog’s annual expenses included $100,000 for security (due to credible death threats), $8,000 for grooming, $1,200 for food, and a $60,000 salary for a full-time caretaker.

What Are the Key Lessons from These Celebrity Will Disputes?

Despite having access to the best legal advice money can buy, these wealthy individuals made preventable estate planning mistakes. The lessons apply to everyone:

The higher the stakes, the more likely a challenge will be made. But even modest estates can be contested if the Will is unclear, outdated, or nonexistent. The solution is straightforward: write a Will, be specific, and keep it updated.

With an online Will service like USLegalWills.com, you can create a comprehensive, legally valid Will in about 20 minutes — and update it whenever your circumstances change.

Related Articles

• How to Write a Will: Your 10 Step Guide to Success
• The Free Last Will and Testament Service – Not All It Seems
• Writing a Legal Will: The Worst Advice We Have Seen Yet
• Can a Will Be Contested or Challenged?
• Pets in a Will: How Do You Make Sure Your Pets Are Cared For?